McCOOK, Neb. -- It’s official. McCook did not win as “Nicest Place in America.” But McCook can still be proud it received Nebraska’s nomination from Reader’s Digest in the annual contest to determine who has the nicest place in the country.
Columbiania, Ohio, was named “Nicest Place in America” from the national magazine. The town of 6,000 has focused its efforts on its Main St. Theater, which allows everyone to be a star and symbolizes that no one is left behind.
The “Nicest Place in America” contest included more than 1,100 nominations, 49 finalists, tens of thousands of online votes and eight judges, who selected the nominations and the eventual winner.
McCook got into the running after a visit by national journalist David Brooks, who was brought to Southwest Nebraska by the Nebraska Community Foundation and the McCook Community Foundation Fund..
The New York Times Columnist visited McCook last March as part of a listening tour and community dinner to encourage communication between those with different viewpoints. Brooks also spoke at the McCook Rotary Club lunch during his two days in McCook. The visit even resulted in a column in the New York Times about McCook and rural America.
After the visit, several community members were encouraged to submit a nomination for McCook. Coincidentally, Brooks was one of the judges for the Reader’s Digest contest this year.
McCook’s nomination focused on the great quality of life in McCook, specifically citing Sehnert’s Bakery and Bieroc Cafe’s positive role in the community. The online comments raved about the hospitality of the bakery and its employees, its’ wonderful selection of baked goods and just a welcoming environment in general, which has been created by Walt and Jean Sehnert and Matt and Shelly Sehnert.
As part of the contest, the McCook Gazette ran more than 20 news articles about all the nice things in McCook that we can just take for granted. Ideas ranged from those who responded after a home north of McCook was destroyed by a tornado to a McCook youth baseball team traveling to Tennessee to visit and play with a sick teammate.
There were more ideas than space in the paper...just showing how nice McCook and Southwest Nebraska can be.
McCook may not have won Reader’s Digests’ 2019 Nicest Place in America contest, but at the end of the day, McCook is still a pretty nice place to live and great place to call home.
By Ronda Graff • November 16, 2026
"Come to the Table" - Thursday, Nov. 19, 5:30 p.m. at McCook Junior High - offers a free dinner but it's about more than just a meal.
By Ronda Graff • November 9, 2026
Larry Pollman received the November 2026 McCook Volunteer of the Month
By Ronda Graff • November 6, 2026
While voting is a serious affair, there can be a lighter side to the election process.
By Ronda Graff • November 6, 2026
2026 SWNE Big Give Again Sets New Records
By Ronda Graff • November 3, 2026
McCook TeamMates volunteer Autumn Miller was named the October 2026 Volunteer of the Month
By Ronda Graff • November 1, 2026
Civic Duty Doesn't End on Election Day
By Ronda Graff • October 22, 2026
The 2026 SWNE Big Give is ready for one day of giving Thursday, Nov. 5
By Dennis Berry • October 22, 2026
We hear lots of words and promises but actions are ultimately what make a difference
By Ronda Graff • October 21, 2026
Color choices are diminishing from vehicles to paint selections but we need color on our sidewalks, in our classrooms, everywhere in our lives.
By Ronda Graff • October 8, 2026
Peggy Been shares her thoughts on creating your legacy because we are all going to pass on. It is your decision what you are going to pass down.